Last Friday, Brooke delivered a speech that speaks directly to this moment, not politically, but morally and theologically.

In the aftermath of a week where telling the truth required real courage, Brooke named something many have sensed but few have articulated clearly: a dangerous ideology is spreading, one that disguises ancient hatred as “America First,” faith, and conservatism.

This is not a debate about Israel policy or partisan alignment. It is a confrontation with replacement theology, medieval blood libel, and a narrative that accuses God Himself of breaking His promises.

We are sharing Brooke’s full remarks below because silence is no longer an option. Truth is the only safe ground to stand on, and it must be spoken clearly, openly, and without apology.

Brooke’s Shabbat Message

Last night, Ben Shapiro stood on the main stage and did something courageous.

He told the truth.

And the reaction mattered.

He showed us there is nothing to fear about telling the truth.

Truth is the only safe ground to stand on.

Ben reminded us of something essential: that when ideas are wrong, when they are dangerous, when they are corrosive — they must be challenged openly, honestly, and without apology.

That is what strong movements do.

That is what moral people do.

And that is what Charlie Kirk always insisted on.

The Problem We Are Avoiding

Right now, there are people in our midst — call them charlatans, grifters, groypers, whatever label you want — who are attempting not just to divide the conservative movement, but to destroy it.

And if we are honest, their goal goes further than that.

They are not just trying to destroy the Conservative Party.

They are trying to destroy America.

They are advancing a very specific narrative — and it is not political.

It is theological.

It is theology disguised as politics, disguised as “America First,” disguised as “anti-Israel.”

And like all bad ideas, it spreads when it is not confronted.

So let’s confront it.

The Narrative Being Spread

The narrative is as follows — and I’m not exaggerating it.

It says that the Jews killed Jesus.

That they mocked him, tortured him, laughed as he suffered — and he suffered badly: they put thorns on his head, he bled to death a painful death, it was very terrible, and the Jews killed him and they laughed.

And because of this, God broke His covenant with the Jewish people.

The Jews have been replaced.

God’s promises were revoked.

And Jesus’ blood was spilled to save all the nations.

But the Jews still believe they have “magic blood” — superior DNA — and that they are better than everyone else, and they rejected Jesus because they didn’t want salvation extended to the nations.

It says that Jesus’s blood replaced Jewish covenant — and therefore there is no longer a Jewish people, no longer a Jewish nation, no longer a biblical Israel — and God doesn’t need the Jews anymore, and anyone who finds Jesus is saved, there is no more need for the magic Jewish blood, there is no more promise to the children of Israel.

The narrative goes on to say that the modern State of Israel is fake, secular, immoral — it’s not the Israel of the Bible — Israel kills babies, celebrates things we label as sinful, they have abortions on demand in TLV, they celebrate gay pride parades, doesn’t adhere to biblical values, and therefore has no right to exist.

And now the Jews have rigged it so that they occupy and have populated Israel again — but because all the nations have been saved there is no reason for the Jews to return to Israel. God’s covenant doesn’t stand anymore.

Jews kill babies, they have abortions on demand, they are immoral, and they worship a devil god — a false God — an angry, bloodthirsty God — and that they drag America into forever wars and force us to kill babies. Good Christians don’t kill babies!

And just like the Nazis, they think their blood is magic and their DNA is better, just like the Nazis believed Aryan blood was superior.

And guess what — American Jews are the same: they are selfish, they are trying to make it all about them.

They corrupt our institutions.

They rig our system.

They cheat — that’s why Bari Weiss is the head of CBS and Bill Ackman, who is stupid, is rich — because they cheat.

They rigged the system and invented something crazy: antisemitism. It’s not a real thing. “I’m not an antisemite — it’s not real.” It’s a legal mechanism to defend their power. And every time someone talks about or complains about antisemitism, it’s really about the Jew keeping himself in power and entrenching himself.

And you can tell who is bought by the Jews by how many times they go on TV, give speeches, make laws, and talk about Israel and antisemitism.

And why does Lindsey Graham love Israel? Because he has a brain virus.

And why does Ted Cruz love Israel? Because he is a heretic who wants to kill babies and works for the Jews and is confused by the demon.

Antisemitism was invented to protect Jewish power, so they can laugh while others suffer.

And good Christians must take Jewish power away.

And along comes Qatar.

Qatar is conservative just like us.

They have the same values.

They care about crime and safety.

They have a lot of resources that we need strategically.

Israel has nothing to offer — they are not conservative, they love abortions, and they force us to kill babies.

Qatar just wants to mediate and to help us.

Because America is in decline, the Jews got to go, and Jesus came to save us from this demon cult.

This is not conservative.

This is not Christian.

This is medieval blood libel.

And those who are speaking this narrative look good and sound good.

What This Really Is

This ideology looks polished.

It sounds confident.

But it is ancient, hateful, divisive, subversive — and it directly contradicts God’s will and God’s word.

Nick Fuentes and Candace Owens say it louder and clearer — but these are all things Tucker Carlson has said.

They are liars.

They do not tell the truth.

They pretend to be Christian, but they hate God.

Their narrative is that of the antichrist.

And let me be clear: anyone who believes God breaks His promises is accusing God of lying.

If you hate God, you accuse God of being a liar.

And if God is a liar, then the entire Christian faith collapses.

Because Christianity rests on one foundational truth: God keeps His promises.

A covenant is not a contract.

A covenant is a forever promise — one that only God can make.

Humans say, “until death do us part.”

God does not die.

We MUST understand this grotesque narrative. We must talk about it and call it out as such.

But instead we are focusing all our hasbara on a pro-Israel narrative.

Instead of calling out Tucker’s war on faith and his war on God, we are stuck advocating that Israel has Arab MKs and nude beaches and abortions and gay pride parades.

We are stuck in a loop — and our pro-Israel counter narrative is not working, not moving the needle, because this is not about Israel — and I’ll explain why in a minute.

Jesus and the Jewish Covenant

Tucker thinks he can mention Jesus and we should cower.

God did not send Jesus to die on the cross so that people should curse his brothers and sisters.

I’m not afraid of Jesus.

I’m related to Jesus.

We all are — Jesus has a lot of common relatives in this room.

Jesus was a Jew. He died a Jew.

His disciples were Jews.

The Gospel came through Jews.

It came first to the Jews — and then to the nations.

Jesus celebrated Shabbat.

He celebrated Hanukkah.

And if Jesus were alive today, he would walk into a Shabbat dinner like this one and sit with his family.

What some of these voices are asking Christians to do is turn on Jesus’s family.

That is not faith.

That is deception.

Replacement Theology Is Heresy

God made a forever promise to the Jews. That’s what a covenant is. God is not a liar. God keeps His promises.

The claim that God replaced the Jews is not Christianity.

It is heresy.

The claim that God revoked His covenant is not theology.

It is blasphemy.

The return of the Jewish people to Israel is the most prophesied event in the Bible.

Anyone who says otherwise is asking Christians to believe that God made a promise — and then broke it.

Tucker is asking Christians to turn on God’s promise and to believe Islam is a religion of peace.

And we were warned about people who would do exactly that.

This Is a Theological War

This is not about Jews.

I’m not afraid for Israel.

The Torah tells us in every generation they will rise up one way or another and try to defeat us.

The Jewish people have survived every empire that tried to erase them.

I am afraid for America.

Because we are in a theological war — a war of biblical proportions — and Christians are being targeted, slaughtered.

We see it globally:

Christians slaughtered in Sudan.

Burned alive in churches in Nigeria just like in the Holocaust — and the Nazis were also at war with God.

Copts murdered in Egypt.

Christian communities erased all over the Middle East.

Christian churches and Christmas markets and Christian bookstores targeted with violence all over Europe.

This is a war of biblical proportions.

These once-great Christian kingdoms falling and committing suicide — with sharia-law cities within cities.

Islam is at war with Christianity and the Jews are just fodder.

Israel/Palestine is used as a distraction from the subversive war that’s happening here.

Brooke Goldstein
Executive Director and Founder
The Lawfare Project

The Lawfare Project is the foremost organization in the world dedicated to enforcing and protecting the civil and human rights of the Jewish people via impact litigation.