GivingFuel provides customers with donation forms, fundraising pages, and basic donor management features. However, it lacks a wide range of payment options and dynamic marketing tools.
In comparison, Givebutter offers built-in email and SMS marketing tools, advanced customization, and several modern payment methods—including Venmo, Google Pay, PayPal, and more. Additionally, Givebutter has built-in fundraising event management, unlike GivingFuel, which relies on third-party platforms RegFox and TicketSpice for event management.
Tap to Pay
Free forever thanks to optional donor tips
For enterprise plus plans only
For paid plans only
$59–$500 setup fee;
10¢–$1 per contact
2¢ per recipient
Up to 10¢ per text
While GivingFuel pricing offers a free Starter plan for smaller nonprofits, the plan is limited to basic fundraising and reporting features—and it comes at a high cost to donors, as GivingFuel charges up to 4.99% to process credit card payments. Nonprofits that want access to GivingFuel's more advanced fundraising features—like peer-to-peer fundraising tools, text-to-give, ability to accept ACH and offline payments—will have to pay more substantial monthly fees.
Givebutter users, on the other hand, pay $0/month to enjoy full access to Givebutter's robust suite of fundraising features.
Free forever thanks to optional donor tips
$0–$349 /month
Plus additional fees for addon features/integrations
0%
Up to
4.99%
Not listed publicly
9588% of donors
9588% of donors
3% Fundraising Page
5% Event or Auction
How is Givebutter free?
GivingFuel customers note how amazing the customer service is in a pinch. Givebutter is also highly rated for its stellar customer support. That said, Givebutter is overall easier to use and more intuitive, which empowers anyone to set up a successful fundraiser in minutes—no matter how much experience they have.
Free forever thanks to optional donor tips
Hear from real nonprofits what makes Givebutter better
Givebutter’s editorial staff aims to bring you the most transparent and objective comparisons possible. We sourced these comparison metrics directly from fundraising platform websites and third-party review sites like G2, Capterra, Trustpilot, and more. Score data gathered on September 2023.
Switch to Givebutter in minutes, and bring everything with you
Givebutter is the most-loved nonprofit fundraising platform
We’re proud to say that that we’re the most-reviewed and highest-rated nonprofit software company on G2, the largest independent software review site. Givebutter is ranked as the #1 software for fundraising, donor management, and auctions based on user satisfaction ratings.