Explore more blogs
Nonprofit Strategies

GiveWP alternatives for nonprofits looking for more features and fewer fees

Looking for a new donation plugin for your WordPress site? Check out the top alternatives to GiveWP to make the best decision for your nonprofit.

Rachel Ayotte
December 29, 2023
Nerd Mr Butter

Table of contents

This is some text inside of a div block.

Table of contents

Share this article

Subscribe

Don’t miss out on weekly insights!
150K+ changemakers already subscribed
Success! Check your inbox, good news is on its way 💛
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

GiveWP is a popular WordPress plugin for nonprofits that want to handle some of the basics of donations like managing recurring donations, allowing gift dedications, and creating fundraising reports. However, some nonprofits might find GiveWP’s free plan to be limiting—additional licenses, features, and better customer service all come at a cost.

To help make the right decision for your nonprofit, check out the best GiveWP alternatives and compare prices, features, and more.

1. Givebutter: Best free WordPress plugin for nonprofits of all sizes

Givebutter is an all-in-one platform that offers robust fundraising features, including a native WordPress donation plugin. Nonprofits can use Givebutter to accept various online giving options such as debit/credit, Venmo, PayPal, Google Pay, and even donor-advised funds through custom donate buttons, unlimited donation forms, engaging fundraising events, and more.  

What sets Givebutter apart is its extensive range of tools, including a built-in nonprofit CRM, email and SMS marketing, and silent auction software—all available for free. In contrast, other WordPress plugins (like GiveWP) require nonprofits to pay for these premium features or find a new solution altogether. 

💰 Price: Givebutter is 100% free to use thanks to optional tips from donors. Plus, 95% of donors choose to cover the small payment processing fee of 2.9% + 30¢ charged by Givebutter's secure payment processors. Givebutter's transparent pricing model means nonprofits can have unlimited feature access without worrying about hidden charges or platform costs. 

✅ Best for: Any nonprofit looking for a free GiveWP alternative—and wanting access to a full suite of modern fundraising tools. 

⚖️ Our take: Not only is Givebutter an affordable WordPress plugin for accepting donations, as opposed to GiveWP, but Givebutter also offers several fundraising gadgets to help nonprofits do more, for less. From peer-to-peer fundraising to auction management, Givebutter makes raising money easy and fun.

Accept WordPress donations for free on Givebutter

2. Charitable: Best for a solid donor-centric experience

Charitable is a highly rated alternative to GiveWP. With over 10,000 active users, the platform is a powerful option for charities looking for a secure, simple, and seamless way to collect donations on their WordPress site. 

Far from basic, Charitable goes above and beyond to make the giving experience a stellar one by allowing users to upload their own avatars, send anonymous donations, and even engage with an interactive donor map.

💰 Price: Charitable pricing ranges from $149-$599/year, and offers a 14-day money-back guarantee. No matter the pricing plan, Charitable doesn’t charge transaction fees. 

✅ Best for: Nonprofits that want to accept donations in a way that is fun and engaging for their supporters. 

⚖️ Our take: When it comes to price, Charitable and GiveWP are fairly comparable, and they offer some of the same basic features and functionality. But for nonprofits that want a few extra bells and whistles, Charitable is the better choice.

3. Paymattic: Best for alternative methods of giving

Paymattic is an easy to use WP donation plugin that offers tons of great features like recurring donation management and report functionality. But what makes Paymattic stand out from competitors is its host of alternative payment methods. 

The platform offers preferred billing intervals, guest donations, custom giving amounts, and supports more than 135 currencies. 

💰 Price: Paymattic offers a free basic plan, with paid plans ranging from $4.99-$19.99/month. In comparison to GiveWP, Paymattic is a much more affordable option for small nonprofits. 

✅ Best for: Nonprofits that need a flexible WordPress donation plugin that provides an array of giving options, especially those in global fundraising.

⚖️ Our take: Compared to GiveWP, Paymattic has similar functionality at a more affordable price point. Plus, Paymattic is sleeker and more user friendly, too. 

4. PayPal: Best for simple mobile giving 

PayPal is a common payment processor that many nonprofits use to accept donations on their websites and fundraising forms. An easy plugin with great brand recognition—which can help bring in more contributions—this platform offers lots of integrations and even a discount for charities. 

💰 Price: Verified charities get access to PayPal’s rate of 1.99% + $0.49 per donation.  

✅ Best for: Organizations that need a quick and simple way to accept mobile donations.

⚖️ Our take: While PayPal is more affordable than GiveWP, it doesn’t have as many features as its competitors. Paypal offers few branding and customization options as well as limited customer support. 

5. WooCommerce: Best for commercial giving 

WooCommerce is an ideal plugin for, you guessed it, commerce sites. For nonprofits that sell products or services as part of their fundraising technique, and need a simple plugin for their online store or product pages, WooCommerce is a great fit. 

💰 Price: WooCommerce pricing starts at $21/month, with the most expensive plan costing $492.75/month. The platform also offers a 30-day money-back guarantee.

✅ Best for: Nonprofits with an online store.

⚖️ Our take: Unlike GiveWP, which is adaptable to a range of fundraising activities, WooCommerce is only suited for niche purposes: on product pages and commerce sites. It is important to note, too, that WooCommerce wasn’t built specifically for nonprofits, so their charity tools are quite limited.

How to choose the right GiveWP alternative for your nonprofit

All WordPress donation plugins are slightly different, so how can you know which is right for your organization? When considering your options, check out features like:

  • User-friendliness 🤳 All fundraising tools should work as efficiently as you do. Make sure the WordPress donation plugin you choose doesn’t require expert knowledge to implement or use, so anyone on your team can access it.
  • Price 💸 Lots of plugins charge fees monthly or yearly, or even by the license. Select a plugin that fits within your budget constraints, or is completely free (like Givebutter! 👋).
  • Customization options 🎨 A WordPress plugin should be just as versatile as you need it to be. Check to see if the tool can be customized to fit your organization’s branding, accept a wide variety of payment methods, and let you determine the donation amounts listed on your forms.
  • Integration capabilities ⚒️ Ensure that your plugin works well with the other tools and platforms your nonprofit uses to avoid any technical issues.
  • Additional fundraising features 💛 A great WordPress donation plugin helps further your fundraising efforts by offering tools like recurring donations and easy reporting. 

Accept more donations on WordPress with Givebutter

GiveWP is a great option for some nonprofits that need a quick fix for accepting donations on their site, but the price—which skyrockets for feature and customer support access—can be a big hindrance. There are plenty of other WordPress plugins that are more affordable and offer the same functionality.  

Givebutter offers the same range of features as GiveWP, without any of the price. Simple and fun, Givebutter is one of the highest rated when it comes to customer service and ease of use. And because Givebutter is truly an all-in-one solution, nonprofits can bring all of their fundraising efforts in one central place, all for free.

Sign up for your free Givebutter account today and see why more and more nonprofits are making the switch to Givebutter from GiveWP.

Methodology

Our editorial team sources comparison metrics directly from sites like G2, Capterra, Trustpilot, BBB, InHerSight, Comparably, Glassdoor, and more. Data gathered on December 18, 2023.
Get started
Set up your peer-to-peer fundraiser for free in just a few minutes →

Share this article

Subscribe

Don’t miss out on weekly insights!
150K+ changemakers already subscribed
Newsletters
Success! Check your inbox, good news is on its way 💛
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Raise funds better, faster, and for free with Givebutter.

Never miss a thing

Stay updated on our latest insights, events, and good news
Newsletters
Success! Check your inbox, good news is on its way 💛
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.