Donor segmentation: 5 steps to increase retention and giving

Struggling to turn one-time donors into long-term supporters? Broad, one-size-fits-all appeals might be the culprit.

Donor segmentation changes the game. By tailoring your outreach to different types of donors, you can craft messages that truly resonate. The more personalized your approach, the stronger the connection. 

In this guide, we’ll show you how to segment effectively so you can boost donor engagement, retention, and revenue. Let’s dive in!

What is fundraising donor segmentation?

Fundraising segmentation is the practice of grouping donors based on shared characteristics—like giving frequency, donation amount, or engagement level—to create more personalized and effective outreach.

Many assume segmentation is only for large nonprofits with sophisticated data tools, but that’s not true. Even small teams can use simple segmentation—like distinguishing between one-time and recurring donors—to build stronger relationships and increase retention. 

How smart donor segmentation boosts ROI

Fundraising segmentation may seem unnecessary, especially for small, resource-strapped, busy nonprofits. But, strategically grouping donors and supporters can help any charity:

• Build better relationships 💛 Donors who receive a customized message instead of a mass one are more likely to engage with your organization. On average, personalized emails have 82% higher open rates than generic emails.
  
• Save time and effort ⏰ With donor segments, nonprofits can spend less time searching for the right message recipients.
  
• Boost funds 💸 When nonprofits create tailored messaging that resonates with different types of donors—whether first-time givers or major donors—they’re more likely to increase donations.

The 5 major donor segmentation categories

Nonprofits can segment donors and supporters using practically any metric. However, some donor segmentation methods are tried and true for a reason.

When analyzing your donor data, consider these categories your donor segmentation cheat sheet to help you group supporters effectively.

Copied!

https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/612f5131b9c94eda2fe9c725/67af9414d5d5edb5ba0024e9_AD_4nXeMBHJjMgCfXTrkEeYbSxTXQrf472HZyM3WSh4gOlwxmYdJKYWEAne34lu_VLEcbJsY_7HyiUwK-1fIvT13CUX6zqGEcK5cfpLqnHXeKmOobqa63vtOnfWW8zB3bbisdp0CmMlZpw.png

Download Started!

1. Demographics 👥

Nonprofits often distinguish donors from one another based on metrics like age, location, and gender.

By doing this, nonprofits can tailor their fundraising ideas to specific audiences. For example, a nonprofit running a disaster relief effort might target donors in affected regions with localized appeals, while younger supporters living outside the area might instead receive social media-driven campaigns.

2. Donation behavior 💸

Analyzing donor giving patterns—how recently they donated, how often, and how much—helps identify top-tier donors and lapsed supporters. Wealth screening tools like DonorSearch can also help identify and group donors who have higher giving potential.

A common approach is RFM analysis (Recency, Frequency, Monetary value), which allows nonprofits to focus major gift efforts on high-value donors while re-engaging inactive ones. 

3. Engagement level 🎟️

Not all donors give money—some contribute volunteer time, attend events like galas, or advocate for your cause. 

Segmenting based on engagement helps you nurture relationships beyond donations. For instance, supporters who attended your annual gala might receive special updates or invitations to exclusive events.

4. Communication preferences  💌

Every donor has a preferred way to stay connected. Some are more inclined to read emails, while others respond best to texts or direct mail. Honoring these preferences improves open rates and donor satisfaction. 

For example, segmenting email-only donors ensures they receive relevant newsletters and not unnecessary direct mail appeals. 

5. Causes and affinities 💛

Align donors with campaigns or programs they’re most passionate about. If a donor consistently supports scholarship funds, target them with updates and donation appeals related to your education initiatives.

You could also group donors by shared interests or affiliations. Alumni donors, faith-based supporters, and corporate donors may respond best to messaging that highlights their specific connection to your cause.

More to explore

Engage donors at every step of the donor life cycle →

Donor data: What to collect and why

Donor segmentation relies on donor data. But which donor data points are the most important? Here’s a checklist of key donor data to gather. 

Copied!

https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/612f5131b9c94eda2fe9c725/67af9414a836112db78ddd56_AD_4nXdFpnxAb5nbVBuIoqv8KDMzFW_i9Lfu4aJC-T5TqKAY12g0_BI4PLfbjxkeiYmHCGdGp7WuS_hdiomswpl55E0QdFqhxZ2IR9SB8e2WkSulPwWdBcMiodDBh33FeRJ5uzWCQIqvFQ.png

Download Started!

Donor demographics 👥

• Age, gender, and location
• Occupation or industry 
• Preferred communication channels (email, phone, social media)

More to explore

Check out the top 4 nonprofit donor database software solutions →

Relationship & connection to your organization 🔗

• First-time donor vs. long-term supporter
• Volunteer experience with your organization 
• Matching gift eligibility through their employer

Giving motivation & interests 💛

• Specific programs or causes they support
• Reasons for giving (personal connection, corporate giving, philanthropy)
• Response to past campaigns or appeals

Donation history 💰

• Frequency of giving (one-time vs. recurring)
• Donation amount and average gift size
• Lifetime giving total
• Last donation date (to identify lapsed donors)

Engagement data 📢

• Event attendance history
• Volunteer participation
• Interactions with emails, newsletters, and social media
• Responses to surveys or feedback forms

How to segment a donor list in 5 steps

A clear, step-by-step process ensures you’re targeting the right donors with the right messages—without wasting time or resources.

Copied!

https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/612f5131b9c94eda2fe9c725/67af9414e06d933851c50734_AD_4nXe2AGrXGkRhuIpDnPhPRQCG-yhy_z_K9dFh6Q1Vpmd6_j_dProuY5BIup8NwUCEnEWMTWUI3QyykHTJ0tnou-EDz2F-FmsJQnGWbozXu92B7nDDUGWPuXskSg_7HElZ-eWLAskB.png

Download Started!

1. Gather and organize donor data 💡

Before you can segment your donors and supporters, you first need to gather all the information you have about them.

• Collect 💡 Obtain donor information through surveys, signup forms, event registrations, and communication history.
  
• Store 🖥️  Keep all of your donor data in a central location. Most nonprofits use a donor management CRM to store data within individual donor profiles (and we recommend you do, too!).
  
• Clean it up 🫧 Remove duplicates, update contact details, and ensure the accuracy of donation records. A well-maintained donor database is essential for effective segmentation.

2. Set segmentation goals based on priorities 🎯

You can group donors in countless ways. However, it’s best to start simple by focusing on one key priority or goal. 

Some common goals for segmentation include:

• Reactivate lapsed donors ⚡ If you’re looking to reengage lapsed donors, focus on giving frequency.
  
• Increase event attendance 🎉 Segment past event attendees or major donors who may be interested in attending future events.
  
• Make a year-end appeal 💸 Target donors who have given during the holiday season in the past or who haven’t donated at all this year.

3. Create your segments ⚡

Based on your goals, group donors into meaningful categories, such as first-time donors, major givers, or lapsed supporters.

With tools like Givebutter, nonprofits can quickly filter records by contact information, campaign, payment history, giving frequency, and more. You can also create unique filters according to your own criteria and save these custom donor segments for one-click access whenever you need them.

4. Personalize your outreach 👋

Once you’ve created your donor groups, you can craft customized communications and campaigns that resonate.

For example, you might send gratitude-focused emails to first-time donors and impact reports to recurring givers.

5. Rinse and repeat 🔄 

Like any great fundraising strategy, the work doesn’t end once you press send.

Monitor engagement and donation patterns over time to ensure your segmentation strategy resonates with your target audiences. Key metrics to assess include:

• Donor retention rate 🔄 Compare the number of donors who continue giving after implementing segmentation versus before. A rising donor retention rate suggests that your personalized outreach is strengthening donor relationships.
  
• Donation growth & conversion rates 💰 Measure whether segmented donors give more frequently or increase their donation amounts. Track conversion rates for key transitions, like turning first-time donors into recurring givers or upgrading small donors to major donors.
  
• Engagement metrics 📩 Assess how segmented donors interact with your content. Higher email open rates, click-through rates, social media engagement, and event participation indicate that your messaging is resonating.
  
• Response to your communication strategies 🎯  Compare the success of segmented campaigns versus broad, one-size-fits-all appeals. If targeted donor groups respond better to personalized asks, your segmentation is improving engagement and fundraising effectiveness.
  
• Upgrade & reactivation rates 📈  Track how many donors move to higher giving levels after personalized outreach and how many lapsed donors return after targeted re-engagement efforts. A strong segmentation strategy helps donors feel valued and increases their likelihood of upgrading or renewing support.
  
• Donor feedback & satisfaction 💛 One of the best indications that your stewardship efforts are working is because donors tell you it is! Conduct surveys or gather informal feedback to see if donors feel recognized and appreciated.

If certain segments aren’t responding as expected—and donor relationships aren’t improving—adjust your criteria or messaging and try again.

More to explore

Discover the 6 best donor engagement software to boost retention →

Common donor segmentation mistakes and solutions

While donor segmentation can be incredibly powerful, it can also come with challenges. The good news is that there are several donor segmentation best practices that help solve them.

❌ Outdated or incomplete donor data: Busy nonprofits often leave donor data maintenance by the wayside. But, not consistently updating and cleaning donor data can lead to mistakes—like sending the wrong message to a donor.

✅ Data hygiene: Use a CRM with robust data hygiene tools to delete duplicate data. Look for platforms that offer automatic updates, so your contact profiles get refreshed in real time based on donor interactions, events, and campaigns. 

❌ Time-intensive process: Creating personalized communications for each target donor group can be burdensome, especially for small nonprofits.

✅ Automated outreach and templates: Choose a platform that offers automated donation receipts, templates for different segments, and multi-channel outreach options to connect with supporters based on their preferences (email, text, direct mail, etc.).

❌ Manual data management: Many nonprofits still rely on spreadsheets or other manual methods for donor segmentation. However, manual entry can make important data incredibly error-prone.

✅ Leverage technology: Optimize your outreach with software that allows you to filter, organize, and export your donor data effortlessly with custom and preset segmentation options.

The best tools for donor segmentation

The right tools can make your donor segmentation and outreach simple and effective. That’s where Givebutter comes in.

With advanced segmentation features that let you understand donors beyond basic demographics, nonprofits can track giving patterns, personalize communication, and create meaningful donor journeys with:

• Donor data management 👤 Advanced filtering, tags, table sorting, and live search simplify segmentation and tracking.
  
• Automation 💌 Tools for personalized email workflows, automated thank-you messages, donation reminders, and targeted fundraising campaigns help simplify your communication process.
  
• Integrations ⚒️ Seamless integration with tools like Mailchimp, QuickBooks, and Salesforce streamline communications and reporting.
  
• Engagement features: Tools like Givebutter’s Supporter Feed and Matching Gifts strengthen donor connections through real-time engagement.
  
• Predictive analytics: Identify high-potential donors for major gifts or recurring giving programs using AI-powered donor management tools that analyze past giving trends and engagement data to predict which supporters are most likely to increase their contributions.

More to explore

Streamline donor comms with nonprofit CRM bulk email →

Start small and build on it with Givebutter

The beauty of segmentation is its scalability—you don't need a complex system to get started. Begin with basic filters, track donor interactions, and gradually refine your approach.

With Givebutter’s sophisticated donor management tools, even small nonprofits can turn raw donor data into personalized engagement—boosting retention, increasing donations, and strengthening community relationships.

Ready to get started? Explore Givebutter's platform and transform your supporters into long-term champions of your mission.

Create a free account →

Effective donor segmentation FAQs

How do you categorize donors?

Donors can be categorized based on factors like giving history, engagement, and interests. Common donor segmentation examples include first-time donors, recurring donors, lapsed donors, major donors, and event attendees. 

What is a beneficiary segment?

A beneficiary segment groups recipients of nonprofit services based on characteristics such as demographics, needs, or location. Understanding beneficiary segments helps nonprofits align fundraising efforts with specific impact areas.

How do you segment a donor list?

You can segment a donor list in five simple steps:

1. Collect or import your data
2. Set your segment goals
3. Create your segments
4. Personalize your outreach
5. Refine over time 

How to classify donors effectively?

There are several effective ways to classify donors. Depending on your strategy and goals, you might segment them by giving frequency, donation size, engagement, or interests.